The murder of ancient Alexandria's greatest scholar - Soraya Field Fiorio

In the city of Alexandria in 415 CE,

the bishop and the governor
were in a fight.

It started with a disagreement over the
behavior of a militia of monks,

and ended with an accusation
of witchcraft

leveled against one of the most
powerful figures in the city.

Hypatia of Alexandria was a prominent
mathematician, philosopher,

and advisor to the city’s leaders.

In the centuries since she lived,

the details of her life have been
the subject of much dispute

and have taken on an almost
mythical status.

But while none of Hypatia’s
own writings survive,

her contemporaries’ and students’
accounts of her work and life

paint a picture of the qualities that
made her renowned as a scholar,

beloved as a teacher, and ultimately
led to her downfall.

Hypatia was born around
355 in Alexandria,

then part of the Egyptian province
of the Eastern Roman Empire,

and an intellectual center.

Her father Theon was an accomplished
Greek mathematician and astronomer;

her mother is unknown.

Hypatia was likely an only child, and
Theon educated her himself.

By adulthood, she had surpassed her
father in both mathematics and philosophy,

becoming the city’s foremost scholar
and taking over his position

at the head of the Platonic school,
similar to a modern university.

She refined scientific instruments,
wrote math textbooks,

and developed a more efficient
method of long division.

But perhaps her most significant
contributions to intellectual life

in Alexandria came through her teaching.

The philosophy Hypatia taught drew
from the legacy of Plato and Aristotle,

as well as the mystical philosopher
Plotinus and the mathematician Pythagoras.

The convergence of these influences merged
to form a school called Neoplatonism.

For the Neoplatonists, mathematics
had a spiritual aspect,

divided among the four branches of
arithmetic, geometry, astronomy and music.

These subjects were not studied merely
for the sake of curiosity

or practical utility, but because they
authenticated the belief

that numbers were the sacred
language of the universe.

In the repeated patterns of algebraic
formulas and geometric shapes,

the orbits of the planets, and the
harmonious intervals of musical tones,

the Neoplatonists saw a rational
cosmic force at work.

Students delved into this ordered
mathematical world

to achieve higher unity with this force,
known as “the One.”

While Hypatia was considered pagan—

a term for traditional Roman
belief before Christianity—

she worshipped no particular
deity or deities,

and her ideas could be applied alongside
multiple religious viewpoints.

Jewish and Christian as well
as pagan students

travelled from the farthest reaches of
the empire to study with her.

The nonpartisan environment
Hypatia fostered,

where all students could feel comfortable,

was especially remarkable given the
religious and political turmoil

that was fracturing the city of
Alexandria at the time.

Christianity had recently become
the Empire’s state religion.

The local archbishop Cyril had steadily
gained political power,

commanding zealous militias of Christian
monks to destroy pagan temples

and harass the Jewish population.

In doing so, he encroached on the secular
authority of the Roman governor Orestes,

himself a moderate Christian, leading to
a bitter public feud between the two men.

Because she was seen as a wise
and impartial figure,

governor Orestes consulted Hypatia,

who advised him to act with
fairness and restraint.

But when a group of Cyril’s
monks incited a riot,

badly injuring Orestes in the process,
he had their leader tortured to death.

Cyril and his followers blamed Hypatia,

accusing her of witchcraft to
turn Orestes against Christianity.

In March 415, as Hypatia was
traveling through the city,

the bishop’s militia of monks
dragged her from her carriage

and brutally murdered and dismembered her.

Hypatia’s death was a turning point
in the politics of Alexandria.

In the wake of her murder,

other philosophers in the Greek
and Roman tradition fled,

and the city’s role as a center of
learning declined.

In a very real way,

the spirit of inquisition, openness,
and fairness she fostered

died with her.

How Amazon Makes Money

Amazon reported record profits in 2018,
earning $10.1 billion in net income

compared to just $3 billion in
2017. Considering the company hardly had

any annual profit until
2016, this represents major growth.

Whether that's gap earnings, operating
income, free cash flow, this company

hit an inflection point at the beginning
of 2018. It's one of the reasons

that the stock
materially outperformed the market.

Traditionally, Amazon has funneled most of
its money straight back into the

company itself, leading to meager
earnings compared to other tech giants

like Apple or Google. But in
spite of this strategy, Amazon has been

making enough lately that there's still
money left after all of its

expenses on inventory,
fulfillment centers and people.

Amazon still doesn't have the types
of profits that other big tech

companies do, say a Google or
an Apple or a Microsoft. But significantly

more than they ever have in the past
and it really allows them to do much

more experimentation with
the core business.

So what's changed?

Though Amazon has long dominated
the U.S. e-commerce market, online sales

are not actually the biggest
moneymaker for the company. Its e-commerce

division isn't even profitable
internationally. Instead, Amazon Web

Services, or AWS, has generated
the majority of the company's operating

income since 2016.

AWS is Amazon's cloud computing division,
comprised of a huge network of

servers providing processing and
storage solutions for companies,

government agencies and individuals.

What that did for Amazon is it
turned Amazon into a technology company as

well as being
an e-commerce and retailer.

Its clients, which include Netflix, Airbnb
and Yelp, are charged for their

volume of usage, the features they
subscribe to, and the services they

use.

AWS really started to grow about four
or five years ago and became a

significant force in computing.

Amazon Web Services continues to get
bigger as a percentage of overall

revenue and it's a highly profitable
business by Amazon's standards but by

most corporate standards. It's doing
something like 30 percent operating

margins.

In 2018, AWS brought in 7.3
billion dollars in operating income and 25.7

billion dollars in revenue which,
for reference, is more than both

McDonald's and Macy's.

In this last quarter, AWS was
58 percent of total operating profit for

Amazon. So it's still clearly the
profit driver for the overall company.

In fact in 2017, AWS was
actually more than 100 percent of Amazon's

operating profit. So without AWS, Amazon
would not have been making any

money.

But though it's a huge
reason behind Amazon's recent profitability, other

areas of the company are seeing
major growth as well. The fastest growing

division of Amazon is its
other category, comprised mainly of its

advertising business. It grew 95 percent
in the fourth quarter of 2018 and

brought in $10.1 billion in
revenue for the year overall.

As Amazon has become the center of
commerce for a lot of businesses, it's

becoming a huge
advertising play as well.

They don't break out the profits
of this, but looking at comps like

Facebook and Google, it's almost
certainly also in that 30 percent

operating margin range.

If advertising continues to grow at
this rate, some analysts even predict

it will be more
profitable than AWS by 2021.

The last segment experiencing major
growth is the third-party marketplace.

While Amazon traditionally buys products
in bulk from wholesalers and

sells them at a slight
markup, in the third-party marketplace outside

companies pay Amazon to sell their
goods using its platform. Amazon takes

about a 15 to 20 percent cut
of the sales, while also collecting fees for

things like storage and
shipping. While Amazon generates significantly

less revenue from third-party merchants
than from products it sells,

margins are much higher, making
it more profitable than the traditional

model.

If you assume even a small
5 percent margin, you're talking about

potentially two billion dollars
in profit just from third-party

contributing to overall Amazon.

Today, more than half of all
goods sold come from third-party sellers, and

more and more businesses are
signing up. Sales of third-party seller

services rose 34 percent in
2018 to 42.7 billion dollars.

You really have to be on Amazon,
unless you are going to go it alone.

Amazon is the only place where
you can instantly get scale without having

to do all of the marketing yourself.

Amazon smart speakers
also have analysts excited.

The last thing I find really interesting
is Alexa. So you now have an

installed base of over 100
million of these voice-activated devices. Over

time, you'll find yourself increasingly
turning to Alexa, and say "Alexa,

order more coffee." And it's one
of those things that will accelerate the

move of Amazon into two places,
the pantry and into the refrigerator.

The boom in all these
categories, from Alexa to cloud computing,

advertising and third-party seller divisions,
raises the question of how

the company should be valued.

At the size of the company now,
well over 200 billion dollars in annual

revenue, it's just really hard to grow
at 20 plus percent. So that means

these investors who have expected
high growth repeatedly every quarter are

now looking at a company with
slowing growth but lots of profitability.

There's clearly some consternation in the
investor community as to how to

value Amazon today.


How Robinhood Makes Money

It's a theme as old as money itself. The
struggle between the rich and the poor.

And it became especially apparent after
the financial crisis. People were losing

money hand over fist in the market,
millions lost their jobs and their homes.

Trust in Wall Street was at its lowest
point in memory. People were protesting

in the streets. One company launched a
stock trading app in the shadow of the

crisis, Robinhood. Named after the
English fairy tale character who took

from the rich and gave to the poor.

Good sword. Good archers. Good fighters. Are you with me? (Cheers)

But those guys didn't start a 5.6
billion dollar company. These guys did.

It's an eye-popping valuation for a
financial company with opaque metrics

and plenty of competition. The young
company had its share of missteps as

well. Too good to be true? Well for Robin
Hood that might be the case. We know that

this practice is highly criticized, not
only from regulators but also from

consumer advocates. Yhey say that they
were inspired by the financial crisis

and all that. Well, guess what? They're
getting a huge chunk of their revenue

from high-frequency trading.
Prompting questions over whether or not

they can handle primetime. But let's go
back to the beginning.

Today's Robinhood, the app, was founded by
two people who were fed up with the way

you had to trade or at least they knew
others were fed up. We're focused on

building an awesome user experience.
Onboarding something like a 150,000

customers in such a short
period of time is is pretty much

unprecedented in the brokerage industry.
The cost to trade had come down so far

in the last 20 years. Since online
trading began, why not make it free?

Now if you want to invest in the stock
market without paying fees, there's an

app for that. Since Robin Hood came into
the App Store, we've saved customers over

five million dollars in commissions. All
in the theme of sticking it to the banks.

The mission of Robin Hood is to
democratize America's financial system.

But there was something else that made
this product work. We were already

addicted to our phones. Robin Hood made
trading easy on the device we were

looking at all day. The combination
incredible growth. The company launched

in 2013, just over a year late, they had
hundreds of thousands of people on a

waiting list. The beginning of 2018,
they had three million customers. By the

end of that year they had doubled that
amount to six million users. The darling

of FinTech. Many believe the company is
revolutionary. Where they are really

groundbreaking is how fast they're
moving and how much they're pushing the

envelope. You know, they can't be
dismissed because there is something in

being able to double time and time again
where clearly you're resonating with

consumers and then this speed at which
are offering new types of capabilities, I

don't think anything companies could
move that fast.

But there are questions about how much
money is really in the accounts. Robinhood

gets a lot of attention because the
account growth has been really

impressive and everything like that. But
there's very little money there. With

Schwab, Ameritrade, we have larger
accounts accounts that are in hundreds

of thousands. Not single-digit thousands
on average, which is the last time we

looked at Robinhood. A JMP analysis estimates

the average assets and Robin Hood
accounts to be one to five thousand

dollars. That's compared to a $100,000 for Fidelity, a $110,000 for TD Ameritrade and about $240,000 for Charles Schwab.

Robin Hood would not disclose
account values when asked by CNBC. We

don't know exactly where the account
sizes are. I suspect that based on the

types of accounts, they're
typically lower acid accounts and so

they're going to be less profitable
today. But I think probably one of the

key things to think about is that a
small account today could be a large

account in the future. Especially, if
you're getting to the customer when

they're young or early in their
financial life. Not only could they take

on brokers like TD Ameritrade and
Charles Schwab, they might just challenge

the big banks too. Especially, if you add
more capabilities and more service and

then service the cash in the account.
Hopefully, you have an opportunity to

compete for a higher percentage of the
wallet. Which some of the big incumbents

are doing quite well today. There are
also other startups trying to take

advantage of this trend. A slew of
investing oriented apps have come on the

market in the last few years, including
Betterman,Acorns, Stash and more. But it

is not as easy to take the Silicon
Valley approach of moving fast and

breaking things in FinTech. There are
plenty of competitors with really deep

pockets and of course tons and tons of
regulation. Some have called out a

hypocritical side to the FinTech unicorn
that makes it not so different from

old-school Wall Street. In October,
Bloomberg reported that the company gets

almost half of its revenue through a
practice called "payment for order flow,"

meaning a company's pain Robin Hood to
be the other side of your trade on the

platform or at least get the first right
of refusal. it's a controversial practice

but commonplace among online brokers. It
means your orders aren't happening on a

public exchange but behind closed doors
in a dark pool. Some say it helps market

efficiencies because companies invest in
making faster trades. Others say, it's

just a way for high-speed computerized
traders to skim off every trade keeping

markets opaque.
The SEC has proposed a pilot program to

look into the practice. There's a concern
maybe it's taking advantage. The

arguments are to improve liquidity. That
it takes what would be a small trade and

aggregates it and allows it to get a
better execution quality. The reason to

run a pilot is to make sure that those
claims are all actually valid. Robinhood

would not disclose how much it makes
from this practice to CNBC but the

company did offer an explanation of the
system on its website saying: "We send

your orders to market makers that allow
you to receive better execution quality

and better prices. The revenue we receive
helps us cover the cost of operating our

business and allows us to offer you
commission-free trading. The question is

can accompany the built a name, literally
on fairness, convinced its customers it's

on their side. One way to do it, is to
offer better interest rates and that's

exactly what Robinoohd tried to do. In
December, the company announced three

percent checking and savings accounts.
Compare that to the national average of

.09 percent offered by most
savings accounts. For the median American

house that's got about 8,000
dollars in the bank, this adds up to a

staggering 240 dollars
a year. Except, the company isn't a bank.

The move ended up being a fiasco. There
are a lot of concerns about masquerading

as a bank. Banks are tightly regulated in
this country and so if you have

something that doesn't have the sort of
safeguards put in place around those

operations and you try and present
yourself as a bank they're not going to

allow that. So I reached out to Robinhood. They wouldn't provide any details

about the potential relaunch of the cash
management account. They pointed me to a

blog post and said to "stay tuned." On top
of all of that, the market may be turning.

While accounts were almost surely growing
with a broader stock market for years,

Millennials,
already scarred by entering the job

market during the financial crisis, have
now gotten just a taste of their first

bear market. Robinhood gained millions
of users just after announcing you could

trade Cryptocurrencies on the platform
in early 2018. But for the people who

invested in Bitcoin the day the company
started allowing crypt

trades, things probably aren't looking so
great. They lost almost two-thirds of

their money by the end of the year. At
the same time, a younger generation of

traders may be willing to stomach more
risk and volatile markets could be an

opportunity for Robinhood. When times
are volatile, consumers typically look

for help or they look for more types of
professional capabilities. So volatility

in the moment can be chilling and can be
startling to the customer. But it tends

to actually accelerate growth. So what's
next for Robinhood? The company claims

its users have transacted over a 150 billion dollars on the

platform and saved over a billion in
commission fees as of May 2018. It's

beefing up its executive staff, hiring an
Amazon veteran as its first CFO, as it

tiptoes towards an IPO. It's not like
Robin Hood hasn't faced challenges before.

We'll see if today's financial product
can live up to the legend.